| Date |
Benefice |
|
Presentee |
Patron |
Previously |
Cause |
| 1285 Mar 11 | Sutton St. Nicholas. | | Martin de Pembroke, priest. [8] | The bishop. | | |
| 1301 Apr 11 | Sutton St. Nicholas. | | Robert de Chandos. | Dame Margaret Frene. | | |
| 1346 Aug 25 | Sutton St. Nicholas. | | Warin de Brockhampton, acolyte. | Sir John le Frene. | Robt. de Chaundos. | Resignation. |
| 1369 Sep 24 | Sutton S. Nicholas. | | Hugh de Bartone. | Roger Criketot, Steph. Lugwardyn, and Sir John, rec. of Moccas. | | |
| 1430 Feb 22 | Sutton S. Nicholas. | | Roger Carewardyn, chapl. | William Crictot. | John Coburley. | Death. |
| 1456 Apr 11 | Sutton S. Nicholas. | | Walter ap Gwylym. | Thomas Walwayne, armiger, of Lugwardine. | Roger Carwardyne. | Resignation. |
| 1462 Jun 16 | Sutton St. Nicholas. | | Roger Bithewey. | Fulk Wallewayne. | Walter ap Gwillim. | Death. |
| 1533 Oct 29 | Sutton S. Nicholas. | | Christ. Walwen. | Richard Walwen, armiger. | Roger Yonge. | Death. |
| 1560 Nov 17 | Sutton St. Nicholas. | | Edward Cowper. | Richd. Walwyn, mil. | | |
| 1569 Jan 13 | Sutton St. Nicholas. | | John Baddam. | Richd. Walwyn and Katherine, his wife. | | |
| 1662 Feb 19 | Sutton St. Nicholas. | | John Watts, M.A. | William Watts. Hac vice. | | |
| 1678 May 26 | Sutton St. Nicholas. | | Benjamin Pritchard, M.A. | William Watts, sen., a canon residentiary of Hereford, hac vice. | John Watts. | Death. |
| 1702 Jun 4 | Sutton St. Nicholas. | | Richd. Witherston, M.A. | John Shepheard, arm., and Francisca, his wife. | Benjamin Pritchard. | Death. |
| 1738 Nov 17 | Sutton St. Nicholas. | | James Rawlins, B.A. | Edward Rawlins, gent | Richard Witherston. | Death. |
| 1760 Nov 27 | Sutton St. Nicholas. | | William Collins, B.A. | Walwyn Shepherd, of Dormington, esq. | James Rawlings. | Death. |
| 1783 Feb 16 | Sutton St. Nicholas. | | Edmund Barry, LL.B. | Mary Shepherd, of Hereford, widow. | William Collins. | Death. |
| 1805 Jul 12 | Sutton St. Nicholas. | | Matthew Hill, B.A. | Thomas Gibbons, [2] of Charterhouse School, a minor. | Edmund Barry. | Death. |
| 1821 Feb 27 | Sutton St. Nicholas. | | Matthew Hill, B.A. | Thos. Gibbons, esq. | Matthew Hill. | Cession. |
| 1847 Feb 24 | Sutton St. Nicholas. | | George Henry Johnstone, B.A | John Johnstone, of Mainstone, esq. | Matthew Hill. | Death. |
| 1898 Mar 17 | Sutton St. Nicholas. | | Theodore Emmott, M.A. | Himself. | George Hen. Johnstone. | Death. |