| Date |
Benefice |
|
Presentee |
Patron |
Previously |
Cause |
| 1275 Nov 16 | Sutton. | | John de Hodenet. | The bishop. | | |
| 1275 Feb 19 | Sutton. | | John de Hodenet. | Prior and convent of Wenlock. | | |
| 1284 Jun 4 | Sutton. | | Walter de Bolesdon, sub-deacon. | H. de Spennes. | | |
| 1312 Mar 12 | Sutton by Shrewsbury. | | William de Pembridge, priest. | The bishop. | | |
| 1315 Dec 22 | Sutton by Shrewsbury. | | William de Barewe, acol. | Abbot and convent of Wenlock. | | |
| 1349 Nov 10 | Sutton by Shrewsbury. | | Roger de Lutteley, clerk. | The king (Wenlock Priory). | | |
| 1362 Nov 29 | Sutton. | | Wm. Martyn, clerk. | Abbot and convent of Wenlock. | Roger de Astone. | Resignation. |
| 1381 Dec 5 | Sutton, by Shrewsbury. | | Richard Astoun, chaplain. | The king (Wenlock priory). | | |
| 1394 Sep 1 | Sutton. | | John Feckenham. | The Crown (Wenlock priory). | | After inquiry by commissioners. |
| 1396 Dec 21 | Sutton by Shrewsbury. | | John Wythyngton. | The Crown. | | |
| 1398 Apr 10 | Sutton chapel. | | John Smyth. | Sir Hugh Burnell. | | |
| 1430 Feb 17 | Sutton. | | Richd. Lye, chapl. | Prior and conv. of Wenlock. | William Lawelas. | Resignation. |
| 1431 Jul 3 | Sutton by Shrewsbury. | | Thos. Salowtone. [3] | Prior and conv. of Wenlock. | | |
| 1481 Mar 19 | Sutton by Shrewsbury free chapel. | | Richard Norton, leg. doc. | Prior and conv. of Wenlock. | | |
| 1520 Oct 20 | Sutton by Shrewsbury. | | Thomas Butler. | Prior and conv. of Wenlock. | Certo modo. | Certo modo. |
| 1554 Oct 15 | Sutton. | | Henry Stephens. | Richd.Walwyn, mil. | | |
| 1579 May 23 | Sutton-in-the-Dale. | | William Harries. | The queen. | | |
| 1661 May 27 | Sutton-prope-Salop. | | William James, M.A. | Thomas Makeworth, arm. | | |
| 1692 May 18 | Sutton. | | James Talbott, B.A. | Thomas Mackworth, arm. | William James. | Death. |
| 1704 Jun 1 | Sutton. | | Jeremiah Kitching, B.A. | Bulkeley Mackworth, arm. | James Talbott. | Death. |
| 1724 Aug 10 | Sutton-by-Salop. | | John Addenbroke, M.A. | Bulk Bulkley Mackworth, arm. | Last incumbent. | Resignation. |
| 1733 Sep 23 | Sutton-by-Salop. | | William Shaw. | Henry Mackworth, esq. | John Addenbroke. | Death. |
| 1738 Jul 13 | Sutton by Salop. | | Thomas Fewtrell, B.A. | Herbert Mackworth, esq. | Last incumbent. | Death. |
| 1762 Dec 23 | Sutton-by-Salop. | | Joshua Platt, B.A. | Herbert Mackworth, of Neath, esq. | Thomas Fewtrell. | Resignation. |
| 1782 Aug 27 | Sutton-by-Salop. | | John Smythe. | Noel Hill, of Terne, esq. | Edward Harwood. | Death. |
| 1797 Oct 27 | Sutton-by-Salop. | | Henry Burton, B.A. | Thomas Noel, lord Berwick. | John Smythe. | Death. |
| 1799 Jan 23 | Sutton-by-Salop. | | Richard Hill, M.A. | Thomas Noel, lord Berwick. | Henry Burton. | Resignation. |
| 1845 Dec 21 | Sutton (Salop). | | Hon. Thomas Henry Noel Hill, M.A. | Richard, lord Berwick. | Richard, lord Berwick. | Resignation. |
| 1870 Jul 15 | Sutton. | | Francis Paddon Girdlestone, M.A. | William Noel, baron Berwick. | Hon. Thomas Henry Noel Hill. | Death. |
| 1887 Aug 9 | Sutton. | | Hen. Francis Bather, M.A. | Hen. Richard. lord Berwick. | Francis Paddon Girdlestone. | Cession. |